| 1960s | Terrie S saw a cougar in Ithaca while driving at night down through the Woodland Park, just a little north of the Ithaca Cemetery. |
| 1967 | Woman who lived west of Ithaca on Rich Road heard a commotion and a large flock of birds flew out from the trees. There was a loud thump of something landing on the ground. Upon investigation, there were feline tracks photographed next to paper plates to show their size |
| 02/99 | Between Shepard and Alma just west of Old US 27 - a large black cat, 40-60 pounds, observed walking along the edge of a farm field | BLACK |
| 10/13/05 | Just N of Alma and m-46 on US 27 near Mile Marker 144/145 |
| 11/14/07 | US 27 - Crossing field into a drainage ditch |
| 10/11/11 | Brian C of Elwell saw a big black cat at 15' while bow hunting. Cat almost jumped on top of him while walking back to his truck at 6:45 p.m. Estimated size of 80-100 pounds. Sheriffs Department called | BLACK |